I had a lot of fun rereading books from my childhood and teen years throughout February, so I decided to take advantage of the fifth Fridays throughout this year and keep revisiting some past favorites. Because you can only flashback on months or days that begin with “f.”
Kevin Crossley-Holland’s Arthur Trilogy has sort of haunted me since I read it as a preteen (I think). It follows the life of a young boy named Arthur who sees the legends of King Arthur played out in a piece of obsidian. Arthur and Arthur-in-the-stone share some parallels in life, but it is up to Arthur to determine how what he’s seen affects how he lives.
The Seeing Stone is the first book in the trilogy, introducing us to Arthur and his family. At 13 years old, Arthur is anxious for his life to begin. His greatest dream is to become a squire, but his father hasn’t committed to that plan and Arthur worries that his dream may never come true. The strange and mysterious Merlin gives Arthur a piece of obsidian and tells Arthur that it’s a precious and secret gift that will reveal power and understanding to Arthur. Not long after, Arthur begins to see things in the stone, legends of Britain of ages past. And though their circumstances are different, he and Arthur-in-the-stone find themselves facing similar challenges and defeats. They are not the same person, but neither are they entirely different.
At the Crossing-Places opens with Arthur finally realizing his dream. He is going away to squire for Lord Stephen, and not only that, they plan to take the cross and join the crusade. But the fulfillment is bittersweet because of all the revelations that have shaken Arthur’s life. With home and family swept from under his feet, Arthur must learn who he is and who he wants to be. The more of life he experiences, the more questions he has about everything he’s been taught and everything he’s told to believe.
King of the Middle March meets Arthur in the waiting. They are prepared to sail on their holy crusade, but things go wrong at every turn. Arthur struggles to reconcile what his heart tells him is right with the hatred and bigotry that drives the crusade forward. Meanwhile in his seeing stone, King Arthur’s knights also struggle with faith on their quest for the holy grail. Slowly but surely King Arthur’s kingdom crumbles, but what will that mean for Arthur’s life?
Crossley-Holland’s Arthur Trilogy explores how history or legends can help to shape and guide a young life. Merlin gives Arthur the stone with no context or guidance for how to use it. At first, Arthur wonders if he is somehow the boy king in the stone. Though he soon realizes he isn’t, in some ways, he still is. The things King Arthur experiences guides Arthur de Caldicot as he navigates the tumultuous years of his youth.
When I read this series as a kid, I didn’t quite grasp just how much Arthur was wrestling with faith and with the teachings of church figures, struggling to reconcile their harshness with the things they say about God. I find it interesting that Crossley-Holland chose to explore this struggle in the context of Arthurian legend and the holy crusades.
Although I generally enjoy anything Arthurian, this series wouldn’t quite be for everyone. At most, it’s about 50 percent Arthurian. But, what Crossley-Holland includes is quite true to the stories. Even down to Mordred being the son of Arthur and his half-sister Morgan le Fay (this is understandably one of the bits that some retellings like to change).
Overall, I enjoyed the series. I remember enjoying it more than I did this second go around, but it was still an engaging story and a bit of a different take on the stories of King Arthur and his Round Table. It’s a coming of age trilogy that reflects many of the challenges and triumphs that each person goes through, even if the details and specifics are a little different for each one.